The Louis Pasteur of Junkiedom ([info]calamityjon) wrote,
@ 2007-06-20 11:19:00
Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend!  Next Entry
Entry tags:superman theory

I'm having something of a stressful morning, so I think I'd like to take an hour off and write a little more about the Superman mythos. So some of you can go "HEY WHAT ABOUT SUPER-HORSE" and I just have a big, steamy make-believe look at you through the computer monitor like "Yeah, what about Super-Horse?"

Anyway, like many folk characters, Superman finds himself acting as protagonist in a number of differently themed stories - primarily he indulges in straight heroic adventure, but he's also got his share of farces, satires (a few), and looking at them in the right light, origin myths and nature myths.

The story of Superman is also a series of love stories, although I've never been much a fan of the central romance; the triangle between Lois, Clark and Superman. Which is a shame, because it is a pretty fundamental romance, if you read it in the right light: The champion, for his own reasons - to better pass unnoticed among friends and hide from his enemies - disguises himself, and walks the streets of the city as a timid, unremarkable youth. In this disguise, he falls in love with a brave, beautiful woman. She, however, scorns and mocks him for her love for the champion himself! Ho Ho! So freed from his disguise, he in turn mocks and scorns her, so that eventually she learns humility and soft-heartedness, and comes to love the timid youth, who then may reveal himself as his true self, the end. Ta-da, that's Byronian shit right there up in this piece, enjoy it.

(The persistent cheap soap opera theatrics of their relationship has basically made it impossible for me to enjoy the romance between them, and the marriage itself has been pretty boring to my mind; mostly, Superman flies into their apartment, they talk about transparent relationship issues, then Superman hears a cat catching fire and has to leave and Lois makes some supportive remark about how it's like being married to a firefighter or a doctor, and away flies Superman. Dull, demeaning. As the perennial outsider, I'd love to see Clark and Lois as a married couple ... at Lois' family's place for Thanksgiving! Or baby-sitting her sister's kids. Or Clark having to throw a bachelor party for Lois' brother or something - essentially, using the marriage as a reason to take an outsider orphan and jam him into family situations with which he has no familiarity - character-building and comedy gold, really)

The romance which DOES work for me is also the most straight-up mythical, it's about as Norse as Thor drinking the ocean and Babylonian as tiny men getting abducted by birds (I think that's how it went). Superman and his love for Lori Lemaris.

Here's how it goes; As a young man in college, Clark Kent is captivated by the exotic beauty of a foreign-born student, confined to a wheelchair. He approaches her, and despite their mutual attraction, she pulls away from. Clark follows her every night to the caravan she keeps by the sea. Thinking she must be embarrassed by her infirmity, he resolves to cure her with his superpowers, and uses his X-Ray vision to peer through the walls of her caravan to reveal - the girl speaking hurriedly in hushed, secretive tones over strange radio equipment. Is she a spy for a foreign power, he begins to wonder?

He confronts her and discovers that she is indeed a foreign agent, but is she from an enemy nation? No, she is a mermaid! Holy shit and hot damn! And worse yet, although they have a passionate and brief affair, she must return to her people where Superman cannot follow (Don't get smart, you know why. You wouldn't want to read Clark Kent swimming to an underwater newspaper every month)

I love this story because IT IS A DAMN NATURE MYTH, the Sky and the Sea, a folk explanation of the tides.

Here, allow me to stitch something up from whole cloth: Every evening, the young figure of the Sky cloaks his burning countenance in night, and steps towards the earth, glowing as the moon. And every night, he sees a beautiful maiden seated upon the rocks by the ocean. He falls immediately in love, but she spurns him. He returns to her each night to her side, and by pieces wins her heart. Embracing her, he spies what he believes to be a knife in her hand, and puts her away from him, fearing she is an enemy of his court, and intends to harm him. She reveals that, no, as he is the Sky, she is the Sea, and he saw only the reflection of his own brightness shining upon her waters. So rebuked, she pulls away from him, and returns to her separate ocean.

That's how I always read the Superman/Lori Lemaris story.NICE HUH? Here's another way, the song "Fish & Bird" by Tom Waits:







Since my time is up, I'm not going to bother with Sally Selwyn and Lyla Ler-Rol, much less Lana Lang, who is a romantic blip. I leave it to you guys, and ezraelMatt Rossi, who can probably do this as well if not better than I can, given his credentials. And his credenza.


(Post a new comment)


[info]calamityjon
2007-06-20 06:26 pm UTC (link)
Seriously, it's a nice credenza.

(Reply to this)


[info]ludickid
2007-06-20 06:32 pm UTC (link)
All this, and you can't dig on a guy in a bat suit.

This is beautifully written, though, and despite my antipathy for the character (and we WILL discuss this Batman v. Superman thing one day, over whiskey, but in essence it has a lot to do with accessibility and...well, not, realism as such, but relatability, and what a child wants vs. what a man, or at least an adolescent wants, and of course our old and inflexible pal personal preference, which seems to have dictated that Supes/Bats gets broken down into a false and arbitrary but nonetheless remarkably persisten dichotomy of "mythology" vs. "psychology" and I just happen to prefer the latter, even in silly clothes, over the former, even in poetic rags), I really could read this sort of stuff all goddamn day.

If you're looking for validation, also, and why wouldn't you want validation from a fat fuck like me?, I completely agree with you both on the dullness of the Clark/Lois marriage and the proper way to spice it up -- as it stands now, we basically are given iterations of stories in which SHE lives in HIS world, which is totally uninteresting and should defer to the much less magical but much more dramatically/comedically rewarding situation where HE lives in HERS (which, incidentally, would serve to make the reverse much more interesting when it DID happen).

>Thinking she must be embarrassed by her infirmity, he resolves to cure her with his superpowers

And, all over the world, millions of cripples roll their eyes and say "Thanks a dirtheap, Superman. Sorry my tits aren't big enough for you."

Hey, how did I miss this Tom Waits thing before? Is this new, for that project you pitched a while back? And is it too late to get in on that?

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]calamityjon
2007-06-20 06:40 pm UTC (link)
It's from the old Open Book series, which I think I did before we met.

Also, I need to probably stress (again) that I don't actually dislike Batman, that I've read quite a few really great Batman stories, and that there are a lot of things I like about the character. It probably comes down to me finding a lot of faults with the way writers approach him, and the ill-considered reasons so many fans state their binary preference of Batman=Yes, Superman=No (The "He's just a normal human" argument being the worst).

Also, inre: the Superman/Lois relationship, you may not believe it there has been ONE guy who did something amazingly interesting with it: Chuck Austen. I fucking KNOW, right? He had Lana Lang speaking frankly to Clark about how she felt about him (She married Pete Ross as a consolation prize, which she stresses isn't to say that she did not love him nor that she was unhappy with the choice, just that if Clark had returned her affections, she'd be with him), that Clark sacrificed much more in his marriage than Lois ever did, and that no matter what Lois might say that it was clear that she did NOT love Clark Kent for Clark Kent, because she was never around when she was needed as Clark's wife as opposed to Superman's wife. Also that Superman may be so passionately and devotedly in love because he was furiously lying to himself about how crappy a relationship it was.

I KNOW. CHUCK AUSTEN.

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)


[info]archaica
2007-06-20 06:42 pm UTC (link)
How can fucking Chuck Austen be the one guy to do something with that relationship besides the standard crap? It just boggles the mind.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]jedibugs
2007-06-20 07:09 pm UTC (link)
I remember that Tom Waits deal...I actually printed it out and got in framed in three pieces for a friend of mine. She now has it on her wall in Albequerqie (I have no idea how to spell that. Forgive me) as she is a huge Tom Waits fan.

Maybe I shoulda paid you royalties on that or something, now that I think about it.

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)


[info]calamityjon
2007-06-20 07:10 pm UTC (link)
It's easier to remember if you pronounce it Al-Boo-Kwer-Kay. Maybe.

I understand other copies of that float around. Some day I oughtta do real prints...

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]archaica
2007-06-20 06:41 pm UTC (link)
And, all over the world, millions of cripples roll their eyes and say "Thanks a dirtheap, Superman. Sorry my tits aren't big enough for you."

Haw!!

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]fengi
2007-06-20 06:35 pm UTC (link)
Have you ever checked out the strange failed Superman Broadway musical, which touches upon the Clark-Lois-Superman triangle and (lightly) ruminates on the Supermyth? It's currently in revival in Chicago and it's probably the oddest superhero artifact I've seen.

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]calamityjon
2007-06-20 06:41 pm UTC (link)
I have two different copies of the soundtrack, as a matter of fact. Linda Lavin can fucking tear it UP.

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)


[info]blake_reitz
2007-06-20 06:51 pm UTC (link)
Dare I ask where you found those? I've been looking for a copy for-ev-er.

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)


[info]calamityjon
2007-06-20 06:52 pm UTC (link)
Dare away! Here's one, and the other is a pretty shitty recording from the ABC Television broadcast from the Seventies, which I downloaded...

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)


[info]jedibugs
2007-06-20 07:11 pm UTC (link)
Once upon a time, I had the official Broadway soundtrack on vinyl. Oh, how I lament its loss.

BAM BAM BAM -- "Bullets can't hurt me!"

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]calamityjake
2007-06-21 12:01 am UTC (link)
Wait a second. I thought Lana Lang was just in Smallville. God damn ass hell, bother with Selwyn, Lyla, and Lang!!!!!

(Reply to this)


[info]revme
2007-06-21 12:08 am UTC (link)
That Tom Waits piece is fucking gorgeous. For reals. My god.

Also, the writing above it is neato too and really interesting. And I really like the idea of the Clark In Familiar/Non-Familiar Situations and all that. But MAN. Waitspiece.

(Reply to this)


[info]fiduch
2007-06-21 01:59 am UTC (link)
first off, i guess i should qualify myself. i'm a huge superman fan, but my collection consists entirely of post-COIE DC, so my expertise doesn't cover the gold or silver age iterations (though i'm still somewhat familiar with them).

that being said, i think the lois & clark relationship has all the potential in the world, but it just hasn't been tapped in quite a while. all of my favourite superman stories involved lois in rather heavy ways: the death of superman, the death of clark kent, the wedding and subsequent honeymoon (the honeymoon in particular i thought was one of the best lois & clark stories). however, as you'll notice, all of these stories are at least ten years old. big blue's recent writers all seem tied up in the (super)man himself, and are generally leaving the supporting cast by the wayside, which i think is a huge mistake. bibbo, ron troupe, lucy lane, professor hamilton, cat grant, jose delgado... these were great supporting characters that have all but disappeared anymore. you're lucky to see even lois or jimmy olsen once in many storylines.

i know this is gonna sound cliche, but we need a classic writer to come back and put the "man" back in "superman". maybe someone like dan jurgens or jerry ordway.

just my two cents.

(Reply to this)


[info]fetorpse
2007-06-21 03:15 am UTC (link)
That Tom Waits adaptation is awesome. You totally beat me to doing it too, but taint gwine stop me! Taint!

(Reply to this)


[info]darkwaterfrey
2007-06-21 04:29 am UTC (link)
Excellent album and song choice from tom waits. Yes, I recieved your delightful "what about streaky the super cat??" message, my point was, in fact, that while I endear myself to all those engaged in the epic (constant) reworking of a true american folk-hero like superman, sometimes it does get a bit tedoius with the over-anaylsis of these basic archtypes. I agree that these charcters can be fit alongside many myths and tales from other cultures, especially superman/superboy, since they a such basic concepts. (Gilgimesh, Hercules, Sampson, etc.) I think that Captain Marvel really nails it with using SHAZAM as a work comprised of gods/famous kings names, and goes on from there.

(Reply to this)


[info]perma_boy
2007-06-21 10:33 am UTC (link)
This has absolutely nothing to do with it, but it's comics-related: you know how you did that drawing of The Atom with a sort of atomic rod some time ago? Well, they gave him one. And now, She-Hulk and Iron Man have had sex. It doesn't specifically say he did her in the can, but one kind of takes it as read. These people are ripping off all your ideas!

(Reply to this)


Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Login w/ OpenID
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…